While it may have started off cute, sweet, and romantic, it quickly devolved into just hours of NOTHING. If you watched Doctors (same writer) and realized NOTHING really happened in that drama....this one was even worse. I love the main actress, but I hated her character in this show. Right now, having just finished it a few hours ago, I am irrationally angry with myself for not allowing myself to drop this drama earlier in the series. I am mad that I sat through 20 hours of meandering and didn't really have any satisfaction at the end.
I hated the way all the main females behaved and how they treated the men in their lives. The only decent female in the show was Soo Jung, the sommelier at Jung Seon's restaurant. Hyun Soo was a terrible character. I thought that Jung Seon had no strength. Hong Ah was a selfish brat. Kyung, while probably one of the cutest to me at first, just became irrationally stubborn in some of the later episodes. Jung Woo was just wronged by almost all of those he was closest to and treated well (save Jung Seon). The parents were not really good people. So, while the acting was decent for most of the cast....I didn't really like most of the characters.
The music was nice, so that is a plus.
I will never ever rewatch this. I could not give it zero stars.
Please do not waste your time on this mess. Not even for Kim Jae Wook's cheekbones which, quite frankly, could have been the sole reason I even finished this stupid show.
Was this review helpful to you?
Story: To be honest the story started our amazing and i'm not just saying that because it started with a sex scene. The events that happened allowed me to get a grasp of the characters and their personalities. Towards the middle of the series things got weird. By that i mean the random events that were happening that just made no sense at the time. I figured it was just filler but then towards the end IT ALL came together. I was amazed and i loved it so much. The content could only be described as juicy :^) The only thing i could complain about was the relationship between P'pu and the teacher. While they were cute i felt it was too awkward and a bit forced. Like they were trying to force something to happen. Other than that it was amazing!
Acting/Cast: So let me just start by saying YIHWA!!!!! she was by far my favorite character in the series. Despite how amazingly cute Korn and Knock were i really loved her acting. She played her part of the pretty mean girl that takes care of her friends so well. Then the relationship between Korn and Knock couldn't have been more cuter. They looked so comfortable during the series in fact I was starting to suspect they were more than just friends outside of the series. As much as i love giving positive feedback i must say that there were a multitude of times during the series where Korn made this weird face. At first i figured it was just something they told him to do but that doesn't make sense as the face failed to portray the right emotion at that time. So for that i have to deduct some points. Also I have seen this in many other dramas and it also happens with the "straight guy's" girlfriend. They all talk weird. Their speech is so awkward compared to the other characters it seems forced and unnatural. Lucky for the series i wont deduct points for something i don't fully understand.
Music: ahem *searches YouTube for Together With Me ost* this series has a good mix of music and i have some of the songs dowloaded because i love listening to them. They also did an amazing job at playing the right songs at the right time. It makes a huge different in the emotion of the person watching when they start to play the opening/ending song at a certain point.
Re-watch value: 10 10 10 10 10 10. I have watched this series 4 times and i promise you that i don't mind watching it a 5th. It just gets so good as it progresses. It doesn't drop any key components that keep the audience watching (except maybe towards the middle where it gets confusing like i said). But by then the audience is already caught in the Korn Knock love story that they continue to find all the pieces come together.
Was this review helpful to you?
Dalam film masalah ini disampaikan lewat elemen fantasi.Untungnya fantasi-nya gak kelewat mengawang-awang,malah cenderung straightforward kalo aku bilang.Sampe sini gak masalah.Yg jd msalah adalah walau filmnya diadaptasi dr novel tp hasilnya terlihat ini seolah-olah kumpulan cerpen.Cerita terbagi mejadi fragmen2 kisah sendiri tanpa ada kisah besar yg mengikatnya lbh kuat.Satu-satunya benang merah adl karakter Sato Takeru.Dampaknya adl kita tdk merasakan impact yg lbh uth dr film ini.Ada fragmen yg kita suka,tp mungkin ada yg kita tak terlalu peduli.Naskahnya seperti tdk ingin memilih 1 kisah sbg fondasi utama dan memilih utk menyangga film dgn beberapa pilar2 kecil yg dihias cantik.Filmnya menarik tp tdk cukup kuat.
If cats dissapear from the world. kenapa judulnya itu meaw? Ternyata hal di dunia ini yang sangat berarti bagi si aku adalah kucing. Kucing, mendekatkan si aku dengan ibu, mendekatkan aku dengan ayah, mendekatkan aku dengan keluarga meaw~. Walaupun tak ada kata, cinta ayah didunia ini ternyata bisu. yang bisa menjawab hanyalah ombak yang ada di pantai meaw~
Mungkin ane salah, tapi film ini menceritakan bagaimana akhirnya takeru bisa menerima takdirnya bahwa dia sebentar lagi akan meninggalkan dunia ini, setelah dia membayangkan satu-persatu bagaimana jika dirinya hilang dari dunia ini, dari memory sahabatnya dan mantan pacarnya.
Tetapi ketika dia hendak membayangkan kucing lenyap dari dunia, he can't.
Dan akhirnya tersadar bahwa ada yang lebih berharga daripada sekedar hidup lebih lama.
Was this review helpful to you?
Untuk sebuah splatter film,Tag ngasih liat kita salah satu death scene terbaik di 2015.Sebuah bis yg berjalan tiba2 terpotong jd 2 dan semua penumpangnya (kecuali 1 orang yg kebetulan lg nunduk) termutilasi dr bagian pinggang ke atas.Pelakukanya siapa? angin. Hah?! ya gak salah kok,pelakunya Angin yg berhembus seperti pedang hingga mampu memotong tubuh. Terus di mana saya sadar film ini tdk hanya sekedar splatter. Jujur awalnya gak terlalu merhatiin sampe akhirya kita tiba di scene pernikahan di mana seorang mempelai wanita dipertemukan dgn calonnya.Dan calonnya adalah......pria berkepala babi. Di situ aku baru sadar setelah beberapa menit berjalan baru di scene itu kita melihat sosok pria,itupun berwajah babi. Selanjutnya Sion Sono semakin membawa kita ke dunia yg makin aneh sekaligus makin memperlihatkan wajahnya. Kita di bawa di mana perempuan adalah 'wahana' bagi kaum pria. Keberadaan dan fungsi mereka ditentukan oleh pria.
Mungkin Sion Sono ingin memperlihatkan bahwa media dan tatanan masyarakat lebih condong melihat kaum wanita sebagai kelas yg inferior.Harus diatur,ditentukan nasibnya oleh yg lebih superior (baca:pria). Dan kita gak ngerasa itu aneh bahkan menikmatinya.Sion Sono menempatkan dirinya di kelompok ini ya dgn membuat film ini.Dia sengaja memperlihatkan perempuan sbg subjek fantasi kaum pria dan disajikan dgn fun.Sion Sono menjadikan dirinya sbg sasaran kritik dr dirinya sendiri.Menurut saya ini yg menarik dr Tag.
Krn hanya nonton sekali mungkin pemahaman saya terhadap Tag msh sebatas wild guess.Tp setidaknya impresi yg saya dpt saat menonton film ini ya seperti yg saya tulis di atas
Was this review helpful to you?
Lee Sang-il sebagai sutradara dalam film ikari ini berhasil membuat thrilling pengadeganan yang pas bahkan menurut saya dia bisa memaksimalkan dan mengeksplore akting masing-masing aktornya. Ikari yang berarti Amarah/Kemarahan berhasil ditunjukkan Lee Sang-il dalam klimaks film setelah melalui proses panjang dan perubahan karakter setelah mengalami rentetan peristiwa yang merubah psikis masing-masing karakter yang memiliki cerita sendiri pada 3 kota yang berbeda. Namun, Interpretasi yang kemudian muncul pada film ini menurut saya lebih mengarah kepada sebuah nilai “kepercayaan”. kepercayaan terhadap seseorang yang belum dikenal yang pada akhirnya masing-masing karakter mengalami resiko yang berbeda-beda. Sehingga interpretasi yang saya simpulkan mengenai nilai pada film ini adalah “kepercayaan yang mengakibatkan sebuah penyesalan yang mendalam”hingga mengakibatkan masing-masing karakter mengekspresikan kemarahan dan amarahnya dengan cara yang berbeda-beda.
Namun sayangnya, dari multiple protagonis yang diikuti sepanjang film ini semuanya masih terasa tidak jelas. Kita hanya diperlihatkan karakterisasi tanpa pernah diperlihatkan dan dijelasan tujuan protagonis pada film ini apa? Sehingga saya pribadi akhirnya tidak bisa berempati pada karakter yang ada.kekuatan dari tujuan karakter yang tidak jelas menjadikan saya merasa tidak nyaman mengikutinya. Jika melihat perbandingan film yang mengunakan multiple protagonis yang dimana masing-masing karakternya mempunyai true karakternya adalah film 3 Idiot, dimana multiple karakter itu adalah Seorang pintar dan ingin belajar tapi tak punya akses (Rancho), seorang ingin menjadi fotografer tapi dipaksa orang tuanya kuliah engineer (Farhan), seorang yang punya permasalahan pada rasa takutnya menghadapi hidup dia hanya berdoa sepanjang waktu dan takut berusaha ingin mengubah nasibnya dengan masuk kampus terbaik (Raju).
Kita tanpa sadar terseret kedalam pusaran cerita karena empati terhadap ke tiga karakter tersebut. Jadi jika kembali pada karakter yang dimiliki di film ikari ini, saya hanya membaca bagaimana ketika karakter mendapat tekanan yang besar kemudian mengekspresikan ketidakberdayaannya.
Akan tetapi, bukan berarti ini adalah film yang tidak bisa untuk dinikmati. Namun saya menilai secara story telling masih terdapat beberapa point yang belum menguatkan dan membuat saya belum bisa menikmati secara utuh jalannya cerita film ini.
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
Each episode brings a different type of challenge. The show does a good job of having a balance with the episodic stories and the main conflict. While all the episodic stories matures our characters, these stories help our leads in to wrap up the main conflict of the show in a neat manner.
The only drawback is the amnesia cliché and the drag around episode 13-15. Even then it is highly recommended to everyone.
Was this review helpful to you?
But Attic Cat went wrong when it broke kdrama romcom rule #1: the drama should make you want the main couple to be together, in spite of their flaws. As I watched each progressive episode, I realized just how toxic Kyung Min and Jung Eun are for each other. I didn't want to root for them to be together; I wanted them to stay as far away from each other as humanly possible. Every shouting match, misunderstanding, and petty catflight took a promising show and pairing and nosedived them both to the point where this this show made me frustrated, angry, and annoyed.
That being said, the emotional immaturity of the leads and the imbalance in the KyungJung relationship are my biggest issues with this show. Kyung Min frequently takes advantage of Jung Eun's kindness, hospitality, and feelings and puts her through the wringer. He is selfish, inconsiderate, and just an all-around jerk whose character growth comes too little, too late to be worthy of Jung Eun's or anyone's affection. He shows inklings at being a decent human being, but will take four giant steps back the minute he does something nice. The climax of his character arc doesn't really come in until the last two or three episodes, at a time where the story should be tying up loose ends and promising us the happy (and healthy) ending we all need. His awful treatment isn't just reserved for Jung Eun alone, but she certainly takes the brunt of it in a way that's both confusing and disappointing.
Jung Eun is just as culpable, with the way she enables Kyung Min's horrible behavior and rewards him with her affection, which is a waste of her potential. She isn't exactly a doormat, but her frequent slapfights witih her rival, Hye Ryun, and shouting matches with Kyung Min prove this relationship is not healthy or worthwhile for either of them. Jung Eun spends most of the drama pining and pouting over Kyung Min's well-documented feelings for Hye Ryun, fighting with Kyung Min about Hye Ryun, or fighting with Hye Ryun outright. KyungJung's relationship is steeped in pettiness and jealousy in a way that is not a productive use of either person's growth as a character and a couple, or a productive use of our time as viewers.
The second leads are not exempt from similar foolishness, especially on Hye Ryun's part - there's a particular force kissing scene that will go down as one of the grossest scenes in kdrama history. Dong Jun, the second male lead and Jung Eun's boss, provides a bit of emotional stability and maturity to the show, but there are times where he goads Kyung Min into jealous fits which do not help the situation at all.
As much as I want to blame this parasitic and unbalanced relationship on the pair being college-aged, I've seen dramas with younger, equally problematic protagonists who actually experience development and growth and end up in more deserving relationships. All throughout the drama, I couldn't help but compare this to Boys Over Flowers, as Kyung Min and Jung Eun share the same general personalities and temperament as Goo Jun Pyo and Geum Jan Di, respectively; but their trajectories as individuals and as a couple are starkly different, as Jun Pyo and Jan Di's climax is much more emotionally fulfilling and they both change to ensure they're together.
Plot wise, Attic Cat does nothing new, and is filled with the same standard tropes that come with cohabitating dramas. If you've seen Full House, you've seen Attic Cat, but with more tolerable leads and a relationship that's actually endearing to watch. The music soundtrack saves this drama from being unwatchable and often distracts from the awful toxic arguments occuring each episode.
Ultimately, Attic Cat is missing the emotional payoff and the maturity needed to make this the cohabitation drama everyone deserves.
Was this review helpful to you?
The only thing that described this drama... What are you looking for romance, action, suspense, science fiction, politics, melodrama you just name it and this drama offer you all... A well written plot with many twists... Ji Chang wook is so perfect... He loved him but his profession doesn't allow him to show it directly... She loved him but her promise to him doesn't allow her to follow him... A mother who is totally in dark and a friend who betrayed his friends for the love he had for his wife... A brother who understand the pain of his elder brother but can't help him more... Many shades of love... Nor every crime is a real crime and not every punishment is meant to be followed it is all about the ideology... Some see love as burden and some as blessing but not everything is about love... A total passionate romantic story with the love for society... Justice is not only what you want others need it too... Sooner or later justice will be done to all...
Was this review helpful to you?
Obviously being from the early 2000's the show is overly dramatic at times. Too much drama means the leads are meeting and separating a lot. Both are second leads are way to elder to our main couple. One is a cougar, while the other is pedophile (not really but they have huge age difference). This show follows a lot of dramatic turn of events, but I guess that is what made me stick to drama. Recommendable to all Hong-Sisters' fans.
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
Takumi-kun Series 2: Rainbow Colored Glass
0 people found this review helpful
Was this review helpful to you?
Recent Discussions
-
BL Drama Lovers Club1 minute ago
-
Official Spam Thread- Report spam here14 minutes ago
-
Ideas/Theories for ThamePo1 hour ago