This review may contain spoilers
An Endearing, Heartwarming Romantic Comedy Indeed!
“Who is She”- I was stuck by this odd question when I saw the interaction between O Mal Sun & Kim Ae Sim.What happens when a yesteryear’s star meets a older lady who desperately wants to sing her debut single? A modern retelling of the popular film “Miss Granny”, “Who Is She” focuses on Oh- Mal Soon, a grandmother who magically transforms into her 20 years old self; the only glitch being that her younger self looks exactly like Emily, an aspiring trainee at Unis Entertainment who has gone missing, just days before her debut. The premise did remind me of “Miss Night and Day” where the protagonist transforms from a young lady to an older one. “Who Is She” uses reverse transformation, but the base concept does sound similar. Oh- Mal Soon wanted to be a singer, a dream she shares with her granddaughter, Choi Ha Na. As she gets a second chance to pursue her dreams, the show will focus on her personal growth as she reignites her passion for music.
Read the complete article here-
https://kcdramamusings.wordpress.com/2024/12/20/who-is-she-first-impressions/#more-1400
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Maybe I'll come back to the review after this ends idk I'm not rlly a fan
I think the series started off strong, the first episodes were well done but as it went on and the storylines kept getting dragged on for no reason (HillTer I'm looking at you) it slowly started descending until crashing. Yea the last 4 episodes could be good but even then I wouldn't bring myself to rate this above a 7-7.5 and that's mainly for a few reasonsEaster pisses me off and makes me wanna turn this off, Hill is fine I like when he's on screen (whenever his romance with Ter isn't getting strectched) but with Ter I can hardly find any redeeming qualities, I heard he's the same the novel but I still don't like him. Particularly with his weird shipping tendencies, like girl your best friend is stressed out of his mind by the amount he owes to Johan, how's he gonna pay it off and also North has to deal with his own and Jo's feelings, what a good friend would do is support him not SHIP him the debtor!? In what world is that a reasonable reaction. Love you Earth but Easter annoys me to no end
But even if the whole debt didn't exist it would still be borderline creepy shipping him with Jo when North hasn't given any indications or signs that he likes Johan. Yea, we're shown that North indeed has some sort of feelings towards Johan but like, Ter doesn't know that yet he continues to ship them to the point where its genuinely uncomfortable to watch, I just feel like fast forwarding anytime Ter opens his mouth bcs I actually don't care about what he has to say. Just take the antidelulu pills and take about ANYTHING ELSE. I like Hill tho he doesn't annoy me
What does annoy me is how Hill and Ter's story was dragged on for more than needed, wdym it took them 12 whole episodes to become bfs when they knew they liked eachother from the beginning, this is no longer slowburn this is just torture to watch as they make ZERO progress 😭They could've very easily wrapped it up by ep 5 and gotten out of the way to leave space for the other couples instead of making part 1 and 2. THERE WAS NO NEED FOR THEM TO HOG SO MUCH SCREENTIME
Now for JohanNorth, I really liked Jo at first, but recently he's been weirding me out with his borderline creepy behavior, not bcs of the debt (that's justified as North kinda trashed his house) but the way he's pursuing North is just not rlly nice to watch. Buying all the places North works at? excuse um wtf that's not cute that's kinda stalker-ish behavior. Idk I feel like Johan's approaches could've been written better like just give advice to North as to why he shouldn't work there instead of BUYING THE DAMN PLACE, he was also doing an awful job at showing his feelings but that's not rlly a problem. I still have some faith he won't be an overly possessive bf bcs I really want to enjoy their story
Anways that's the end of my rant, idk if any of this made sense but thanks for coming to my ted talk
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
watch if you're in the right mood.
I liked this show, it was different. It wasn't too gushy but showed harsher realities of the characters. It was a bit hard to get through, but so worth it. The mum not liking the ML was annoying, but it happens. The reason it wasn't a 10/10 for me was because it was a bit harsh for me, or sad. I understand that this isn't really the best reason, but it was just my opinion. Overall, i recommend as a good little show, wasn't prefect, but it was good.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
recommend
I don't have too many shows where they get a q10, but this one was def one of them. I liked this show so much and i enjoyed the plot. I usually struggle to even watch 16 eps, so the fact this one has 20 and i really enjoyed it shows how great it is. The acting and actors did a great job and i don't really think i would replace any of them. If you like not too much romance or watch a little break, but still want a little hint of it, i recommend this show. They only kissed like one if i remember right and the rest was focused on Vincenzo's and Hong whatevrrs mission. I really like the storyline with the younger and older brother, i was super sad to see the younger one die, but it added to the story. Also, the last frames of torture were gruesome, but phenomenal.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
WATCH
This show is great honestly. I liked the plot, and the writers did an outstanding job. I liked how cold and "stranger" he seemed at first. As the show goes on, they become closer, and he begins to care for her more and think about what it is he is doing. The only part i could say annoyed me was the second couple. Idk I'm such a bitch about the second couple so don't mind me (pls.) I just usually get annoyed when too much of the screen time for the second couple is taken up. but thats okayyyy it was messy, but okay. I'd recommend to anyone reading this to watch it. solid show.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
solid 7.
The show was good, not great, or fantastic, just good. The plot was not bad and kept the watcher engaged, until it was doing too much bouncing around. It honestly just stresses out the watcher, which can be pulled off but it wasn't. The plot with the russian gurl and the brother was so dumb, idk maybe im tripping but i feel like they should focus more on pushing the ML and FL story not some brotherly brawl lol. I'd still recommend just because its a classic but "idk." thats how i feel about it.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
BUNS.
This shit was highkey buns. I watched it years ago. like three. I watched it thinking it was going to be like k drama because it was the first j drama id ever watched. The plot was fucking weird, i deadass have no fucking clue how or why i finished it. When i first started watching asian dramas, even if i didn't really like a show, i would still finish it so they weren't just left hanging, idgaf now, but i did then. DONT WATCH. i remeber he had that weird condition where you know what lowkey doesn't work but yeah, this plot was weird and idk just no TUTWas this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
distance.
I think this show had a great cast, but they lowkey ruined it. maybe i should rewatch since it's been like years since i have last seen this show. The acting was great and i really like park jihoon and his works, but this plot was strange. It was like a love triangle between the FL and the friend who ends up living with the ML. Idk it was strange. I wouldn't really recommend and i don't think about this show often. Just Jihoon lol. great actor.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
different and unique
I think this show is kinda one of its kind. It's not every drama where they take this kind of style, and this is why i was fond of this show. honestly the show was kinda mid and that shows through my low score. i think it's the fact that i was feeling rushed to finish it. I liked the beginning, but eventually it wasn't the best. I found it weird how they were asking her to leave the son, but the director tried to convince the watcher that they have broken up. This is common, but they executed it badly. Overall, it was alright, not the best and yeahhhhhWas this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
good development
Overall: I enjoyed the back and forth with the leads/their dynamic. 50 episodes between 1-2 minutes each aired on Vigloo app which also has (Match Play, Rule #1 No Dating Rule, Love in the Apocalypse - My Man's Man is from a female character's perspective and I wouldn't call it a BL series)Content Warnings: punch, blackmail, homophobia
What I Liked
- caring moments
- non dead fish lip press kiss
- stood up/supported partner
Room For Improvement
- background music was too loud at times
How to Watch for Free (episodes are 50 coins each, you can't skip episodes but once unlocked they stay unlocked forever, there are additional tasks to get more coins like following the company on social media)
Day 1
- watch episodes 1-7 (free on the app)
- can watch 10 episodes free with ads, I unchecked the auto unlock, clicked off of that box and another box popped up saying "view ads to watch for free 0/10" (I did that for eps 8-26)
- watch 15 ads per day for 30 coins each on the rewards page and do the daily check in (eps 17-25)
Days 2 & 3
- watch the 10 episodes, do the daily checking, watch the 15 ads per day (should take 2-3 days in total to watch for free)
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Pretty Good Show.
I think this show was good and the acting/cast was great. The plot was good as I didn't feel like I was rushing to finish it, and I liked how cringe/romantic they went about it. The reason it's not a ten out of ten was because they did the weird plot thing where they someone knew each other when they were kids, it's kinda weird and wayyy overdone. I would totally recommend that if you're reading this, you should watch this drama if you haven't done this yet.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
chefs kiss
this drama is so good that i've already rewatched it twice. i don't even know where to begin on how good it is.the plot line was executed so well. the acting was so beautiful, especially from woo dohwan and his enticing eyes. the sad scenes with the OST was so beautiful as well, and made everything 10x sadder.
although haejo's death is revealed within the first episode, it definitely still hits you very hard at the end, especially the "i want to live."
everything about this drama was just amazing and very thorough, and although there was only 10 episodes, it didn't feel rushed and felt very completed.
i would 100% recommend this if you love tearjerkers
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
No
A 10-hour-late head pop.Just wasn't for me. Maybe you will get more out of it!
This drama is a train wreck. If you're looking for anything good – a decent story, interesting characters, watchable acting – just turn around now. Seriously, save yourself. This thing is a mess, and it's not just a harmless mess; it actually pushes some pretty toxic stuff, especially with the male lead.
The biggest problem is the writing. It's just bad. The story jumps all over the place, like the writers just threw a bunch of random scenes together and called it a plot. Nothing makes sense, and you're constantly wondering what's going on. The dialogue is even worse – it's full of cheesy lines and awkward conversations that'll make you cringe so hard you might pull a muscle. You won't remember a single line five minutes after you hear it. And the pacing? Don't even get me started. It's either dragging on forever or rushing through important stuff, which makes the whole thing super boring.
But the absolute worst part? The male lead. This guy is a walking red flag. He's not just bland; he's straight-up toxic. He's controlling, he ignores everyone's feelings, and he has zero respect for boundaries. And the worst part? The show acts like this is okay, even romantic sometimes, which is a seriously messed-up message to send. The actor doesn't help things either. His performance is so wooden and lifeless; it's like watching a robot try to act human, but a robot programmed with toxic masculinity. You never get why he does anything, you never feel for him, and you definitely don't root for him. He's just there, being awful and making the whole thing worse. His behavior shouldn't be excused; it should be called out.
And the side characters? They're totally useless. They're just there to move the terrible plot along, and they have no personalities of their own. They barely get any screen time, and when they do, they don't do anything interesting. They're just… there. They don't add anything to the story, and you forget about them as soon as they're off-screen. They're like background extras who accidentally wandered into the foreground. And they just accept the male lead's awful behavior, which makes it seem even more normal than it should.
The lack of decent side characters just makes the male lead's awfulness even more obvious. He's supposed to be the main focus, but he's completely empty and, honestly, kind of scary. There's no connection between any of the actors, especially with him, which makes everything even more awkward and uncomfortable.
Pros:
• It's a great example of what not to do in a drama.
• It's short, so at least you won't waste too much time on it (but even a little is too much).
• It might get people talking about toxic masculinity in shows.
Cons:
• The writing is awful.
• The characters are boring and badly written, especially the male lead, who's also toxic.
• The acting is terrible, especially from the male lead.
I hope that Lee You Mi gets better script next time. Definitely want to see her in more FL roles. This just isn’t it.
Was this review helpful to you?
Best drama in 2024!!!
Everything was amazing, actors, music, plots and I hope for a second season!! And really I don't understand people who hate this drama. It was perfect!!! very recommendEverything was amazing, actors, music, plots and I hope for a second season!! And really I don't understand people who hate this drama. It was perfect!!! very recommend
Everything was amazing, actors, music, plots and I hope for a second season!! And really I don't understand people who hate this drama. It was perfect!!! very recommend
Was this review helpful to you?
Recent Discussions
-
Fanfictions22 minutes ago
-
Thai Watch Challenge 202532 minutes ago
-
What's the Last Anime Episode You Watched? #236 minutes ago
-
new to wuxia46 minutes ago
-
Last Asian Song You Listened To?50 minutes ago