Editorials Details
- Last Online: 2 days ago
- Gender: Female
- Location: The Internet
- Contribution Points: 21,428 LV28
- Roles:
- Join Date: January 5, 2014
- Awards Received:
5
44
1
1
1
2
3
1
1
Editorials
Editorials
News
5
44
1
1
1
2
3
1
1
And because I'm a petty, terrible person sometimes it's like this. Say, I'm not sure about my rating. Should I give a drama a 7, 7.5, or an 8? If it's highly rated here on MDL, chances are I'd give it a 7 or 7.5. But if it's low rated, it's more likely for me to give it an 8.
Thank you for writing this article, DragonAlien. I love it so much!
Reading the synopsis of Hwayugi, I had the impression that they're going to make a loveline between this drama's version of the Monkey King and Tripitaka, and I was like NO! Forgive me if I'm wrong, but by making a romantic love a focal point in this new adaptation, I feel like they're betraying the central theme of JTTW somehow? And anyway if they want to add some romance, why does it have to be between those two characters?
I'm a sucker so I'll still watch it, but I do hope that I'm mistaken in my impression.
With Stranger and Prison Playbook, I think Netflix released the episodes a week after they're aired in South Korea. With other dramas like Argon and Night Light, they're only available months after they're finished airing in Korea, but for these dramas, Netflix released the episodes all at once.
For Hwayugi, I hope it's the former and not the latter.
You know how illegal sites take people's works for free without crediting the source (and earning some money from ads, when they don't even pay for the content or even sub the dramas themselves), and some fansubbers simply don't want their work being commercialized in any way.
Overall, like you, I still enjoyed this drama immensely, but to think that it could've been better . . . oh, I'm so bitter.
And I second coval's rec: Nigeru wa Haji da ga Yaku ni Tatsu presented the same topic (contract marriage) but in a better way, IMO.
I can't agree more with what namopanik said. I think the screenwriter was trying to generate more tension and angst, at best, or simply being pretentious, at worst.
What bothered me the most about Ji-ho's decision on ep.15 was how out of character it was. She doesn't play games, so for her to say that she wanted to break the contract and then left all of a sudden--without explaining that she wanted to make a new connection with Se-hee, one based on genuine love rather than just mutual need and compatibility--didn't make any sense.
And since she had come to understand to seriousness of marriage, it also didn't make sense for her to announce to everybody that she's getting a divorce. Why not just talk it out with Se-hee, and thus spare their parents distress?
Sorry for the word vomit. It might sound like I hate this drama, which is not true at all. I still rated it 7, but if it's not for the last two episodes, I would've rated it higher.
Anyway, great list! :)
I generally prefer to read the original novel (or manga) rather than watching its adaptation, if I can get my hand on it. And sadly, I'm one of those boring types who is never satisfied with a cinematic adaptation once I read the original work, complaining that such and such is not faithful to the original, bla, bla, bla :D